Online reviews hold enormous influence over consumers’ purchasing decisions—impacting an estimated $3.8 trillion in global e-commerce spending each year. But with that influence comes opportunity for manipulation: fake reviews, both positive and negative, are widespread, often orchestrated by businesses or third-party agencies. Learning to identify fake or worthless reviews is essential for making smart choices and avoiding deceptive practices.
Below you’ll find ten powerful strategies to spot fake and useless reviews, with clear examples and references to enhance your confidence in navigating online feedback.
1. Extreme Negative or Positive Emotion
Fake reviews frequently swing to extremes. They might be overly enthusiastic—“This is the BEST product I’ve ever used in my entire life!”—or intensely negative—“Absolutely horrible, ruined my day!” Genuine reviews tend to be balanced, noting both strengths and weaknesses. Watch out for language that feels exaggerated, as it’s a classic marker of inauthenticity[5][1].
Example :
“Amazing, amazing, AMAZING! I will never use anything else for the rest of my life. If you don’t buy this you’re crazy!”
Such gushing or heated negativity usually isn’t typical of real customer experience.
2. Personal Stories and Details
Some fake reviews attempt to seem authentic by weaving elaborate personal anecdotes that often read as scripted or implausible. Reviewers may fabricate entire scenarios to either praise or bash a product. If the story feels forced or unrelated to the product, be skeptical[3].
Example :
“As a single mother of three who just moved to a new city, this blender changed my life by making school mornings a breeze!”
When stories appear designed to manipulate your emotions rather than provide actual product feedback, consider the source.
3. Excellent or Poor Grammar
A high frequency of fake reviews shows up in poor grammar or awkward phrasing, often due to non-native writers or bots; conversely, some fabricated reviews are suspiciously flawless. Excessive spelling mistakes, inconsistent use of tenses, or robotic-sounding sentences are all warning signs[3][5].
Example :
“This produk is so good, my family love very much. Will buy always.”
On the flip side, reviews that sound too polished or generic—without real substance—are also suspect.
4. Excessive Humor
If a review is filled with jokes, puns, or attempts at comedic flair that seem out of place, it may be fake. Humor is sometimes used to distract from a lack of genuine experience or hide thinly-veiled advertising.
Example :
“This vacuum sucked so well, I thought my dog would disappear! It’s the Chuck Norris of floor cleaners!”
While humor does appear in authentic reviews, watch for it being used to mask a lack of real content.
5. A Focus on Irrelevant Details
Fake reviewers often pad their writing with tangential details instead of valuable feedback on the product or service itself. This tactic creates the illusion of depth but lacks useful specifics about the actual experience[5].
Example :
“The delivery person wore a blue shirt and the box was square. My neighbor’s dog barked as I opened the door.”
When information strays from the core value or issues of the product, treat the review with caution.
6. Reviewer Didn’t Actually Purchase the Product
Genuine reviews are typically linked with verified purchases. Most e-commerce platforms indicate if a purchase has been verified. Be wary of reviews where the reviewer hasn’t actually bought or used the item—these are far more likely to be fake[4].
7. Mention of a Free Product
While some brands legitimately offer products in exchange for honest feedback, a glut of reviews mentioning free or discounted items often signals a coordinated campaign[4]. If positive reviews overwhelmingly come from those who received freebies, be skeptical about their objectivity.
8. Website-Controlled Reviews
Some businesses fake reviews on their own sites, where moderation is entirely under their control. If all on-site reviews are suspiciously glowing and lack any negative feedback, they may not be trustworthy[1].
9. Generic Reviewer Profiles
Check out the reviewer’s name and profile. Fake reviewers often use generic names (like John Smith), random letters and numbers, or lack a profile photo altogether[1][4]. They may also leave reviews for an odd mix of unrelated products across the world in very short timeframes, which is a major red flag[1].
10. Comparing Competing Products or Brands
If a review spends more time propping up a competitor than providing actual insight into the product, it’s likely been planted. This technique is often used to subtly (or not-so-subtly) direct customers away from one brand and toward another[1].
Examples of Fake Reviews in Action
Here’s how several of these warning signs might show up:
- A blender review stating, “Life-changing! As a tired mom, mornings are now joyful. Better than ANY competitor’s blend. I got mine for free and everyone should do the same!” demonstrates excessive positivity, a personal story, competitor mention, and free product disclosure.
- An electronics review saying, “Is fantastic, product works wow. My friend say me buy and I happy,” shows signs of poor grammar and possibly a fake or overseas-written review.
- A restaurant review packed with, “The waiter’s shoes were red, and I liked the jazz music. By the way, I wish I’d eaten across the street!” distracts from actual food or service feedback with irrelevant details and competitor comparison.
How to Protect Yourself
- Always check for a “verified purchase” badge.
- Read reviews on multiple trusted platforms, not just the brand’s own site.
- Use fake review detection tools like Fakespot or ReviewMeta for added confidence[2][5].
- Investigate reviewer profiles for signs of dubious activity.
As always, if you found this article helpful please subscribe to our blog and share this post. Thanks!
References
1. Elfsight Blog: How to Spot Fake Reviews: Best Practices for Finding Red Flags
2. Fakespot: Analyze and identify fake reviews and counterfeits
3. Thrive Internet Marketing Agency: How To Spot Fake Online Reviews
4. BBB: How to spot a fake review
5. InMoment: Fake Reviews: How to Spot and Address Them
